Upravnosudska kontrola postupaka izvlaštenja

graduate thesis

• Title (english): Judicial review of expropriation procedures
• Author: Ivana Suknaić
• Mentor: Mateja Held (mentor)
• Committee member: Mateja Held (predsjednik povjerenstva)
• Committee member: Lana Ofak (član povjerenstva)
• Committee member: Marko Turudić (član povjerenstva)
• Granter: University of Zagreb; Faculty of Law; (Administrative Law); Zagreb
• Defense date and country: 2024-09-24, Croatia
• Scientific / art field, discipline and subdiscipline: SOCIAL SCIENCES; Law

Abstract

Rad započinje objašnjenjem sustava upravnog prava i sudskog nadzora nad pojedinačnim aktima javnopravnih tijela koji se smatraju izuzetno važnima u svakom pravnom sustavu usmjerenom na održavanje vladavine prava i zaštitu prava građana te drugih pravnih subjekata. Izvlaštenje, kao i drugi upravni akti doneseni od strane javnopravnih tijela često ostavljaju dubok i neposredan utjecaj na pravni položaj pojedinca što rezultira nužnošću osiguravanja učinkovitih mehanizama kontrole njihove zakonitosti. Ovaj rad temelji se na analizi upravnosudske kontrole postupaka izvlaštenja u Republici Hrvatskoj s naglaskom na pregledu Zakona o izvlaštenju i određivanju naknade te na relevantne sudske odluke koje oblikuju praksu upravnih sudova. Kroz studiju slučaja prikazuju se konkretni primjeri sudske intervencije u postupcima izvlaštenja dok se u usporedbi s praksom drugih zemalja ocjenjuje efikasnost i pravednost hrvatskog sustava. Unutar rada, analiziraju se kontrolni mehanizmi djelovanja upravnih sudova, pri čemu se uzima u obzir njihova slojevitost i sveobuhvatnost kroz mehanizme koji omogućuju kontrolu ustavnosti i zakonitosti odluka sudova kao i kroz ostale kontrolne mehanizme. Prvi spektar kontrolnih mehanizama uglavnom proizlazi iz temeljnog zakona kojim je reguliran upravni spor dok je drugi spektar arhetipski povezan s organizacijskim propisima. Iako ovi spektri kontrolnih mehanizama proizlaze iz različitih vrsta propisa nedvojbeno je da zajedno čine komplementarnu cjelinu.

Abstract (english)

The paper begins by explaining the system of administrative law and judicial oversight of individual acts of public bodies, which are considered essential in any legal system focused on upholding the rule of law and protecting the rights of citizens and other legal entities. Expropriation, like other administrative acts issued by public bodies, often has a profound and immediate impact on the legal status of individuals, necessitating the establishment of effective mechanisms for ensuring the legality of such acts. This paper is based on an analysis of administrative judicial control over expropriation proceedings in the Republic of Croatia, with an emphasis on reviewing the Expropriation and Compensation Act and relevant court decisions that shape the practice of administrative courts. Through case studies, specific examples of judicial intervention in expropriation proceedings are presented, while a comparison with the practices of other countries evaluates the efficiency and fairness of the Croatian system. The paper examines the control mechanisms of administrative courts, taking into account their complexity and comprehensiveness through mechanisms that enable the control of constitutionality and legality of court decisions, as well as other control mechanisms. The first set of control mechanisms primarily arises from the basic law governing administrative disputes, while the second set is archetypically related to organizational regulations. Although these sets of control mechanisms originate from different types of regulations, it is clear that they together form a complementary whole.

• Keywords: kontrolni mehanizmi; izvlaštenje; nadzor; ocjena zakonitosti odluka; kontrola; odgovornost uprave
• Keywords (english): control mechanisms; expropriation; oversight; review of legality of decisions; control; administrative accountability.
• Language: croatian
• URN:NBN: urn:nbn:hr:199:604148
• Study programme: Title: Public administration; Study programme type: professional; Study level: graduate; Academic / professional title: magistar/magistrica javne uprave (magistar/magistrica javne uprave)
• Type of resource: Text
• File origin: Born digital
• Access conditions: Open access
• Created on: 2024-09-27 07:40:14